| Platinum | Genna Pizza Company |
| Gold | Amici's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | New York Pizza & Pasta |
| Bronze | Frankies Italian Deli |
| Top Pick | Amici Family Bakery |
| Top Pick | Bella Luna |
| Top Pick | Leaning Tower of Pizza and Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Manny's Cucina Napoletana |
| Top Pick | Napoli Pizza N Pasta |
| Top Pick | Slices Pizza |