| Platinum | Ember & Oak |
| Gold | The Dock At River Rocks |
| Silver | Shells of Melbourne |
| Bronze | Crystal Buffet Hibachi & Grill |
| Top Pick | Coastal Crab Company |
| Top Pick | Direct Seafood Outlet |
| Top Pick | New England Eatery & Pub |
| Top Pick | Q's Crackin Crab & Seafood |
| Top Pick | Squid Lips |
| Top Pick | Umami Restaurant and Sushi Bar |